KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent, CMC – A United States-based St. Vincent and the Grenadines national has been freed of charges that he made threats to murder Prime Minister Dr Ralph Gonsalves.
Senior prosecutor Adolphus Delplesche said the prosecution had withdrawn the charges against Paul Scrubb because of a lack of evidence.
Scrubb who was arrested at the ET Joshua Airport in July 2016, as he was about to return to the United States after a five-week vacation here, had been charged with making threats to murder Prime Minister Gonsalves and members of his family and making seditious utterances.
“We couldn’t sustain the charges,” Delplesche told the Caribbean Media Corporation (CMC) after he had earlier informed Chief Magistrate Rechanne Browne-Matthias that the prosecution was not proceeding against the accused.
The prosecution had alleged that Scrubb, a calypsonian, who uses the stage name “I-Madd”, between December 9 and 31, 2015, “maliciously sent or uttered threats to kill, to wit, ‘Ralph Gonsalves should be assassinated, also his whole damn family period … Blessed love” contrary to Criminal Code”.
He was also charged that with uttering “seditious words that “Ralph Gonsalves should be assassinated, also his whole damn family period”.
Scrubb was not required to plead when he appeared in court last July and was granted bail but barred from leaving the country.
The prosecution had then asked for a three-month adjournment but was still not ready to proceed when the case was called on October 31.
Scrubb’s bail conditions were reviewed and he was allowed to leave the country.
His lawyers, Israel Bruce and Sherlan “Zita” Barnwell, welcomed the prosecution’s decision not to proceed against him.
“The prosecution team and the court, in combination, made a very important decision not to proceed with this matter against Mr Scrubb,” Bruce told CMC, noting that he had said last July, when Scrubb was arraigned, that the charges were politically motivated.
“I proffered that it was a deliberate and intentional move by the state to silence Mr. Scrubb,” he said and suggested that Scrubb was pursued because of his songs.
“Mr. Scrubb, as you know, has made a number of hit songs against the ruling regime and I am satisfied in my mind — I said it then, and I maintain now — that it was an effort to try to silence him,” Bruce said.
The defence counsel noted the threats were allegedly made in December 2015 and Scrubb was arrested at the ET Joshua Airport in July 2016, as he was about to return to the United States.
“They waited until the very moment he was about to board and aircraft to leave St Vincent to charge him, to ensure that there was maximum effect for public humiliation,” Bruce said, adding that the prosecution then came to court and asked for a three-month adjournment “to get evidence.
“That was the request — to get evidence to proceed with the matter,” he said of the prosecution’s application for an adjournment last July.
Bruce said he maintains, as he argued last July, that the Crown has a duty to satisfy the two-fold Full Code Test, the first leg being a determination of whether they had enough evidence to substantiate the charge and if so, if it is in the public’s interest to prosecute.
“And when you make an application to get three months to get more evidence to carry the matter, it is saying one single thing: you did not surpass the evidential threshold, which was a must before you proceed to charge.”
Scrubb said he was pleased with the outcome “because justice has been served.
“I am innocent of what they charged me. I always knew I was innocent, I always knew it wouldn’t amount to anything but I thank my counsel and justice has been served and I give thanks to the almighty.
“But it just held me back from moving forward and doing some things, but God is good. I’m just happy. The world sees and the world knows what is going on in St. Vincent and the Grenadines,” Scrubb said adding that he could not have gone back to his job in the United States.